Twenty-two local baseball and softball players, 11 boys and 11 girls, have been selected to the All-Greater Cortland teams for their performances during the 2024 season. There are two pitchers, two catchers, four infielders and three outfielder chosen for each team.
The players were selected from the 10 local schools and were chosen based on statistics and the way they impacted games.
Here are the players selected:
BASEBALL
Cal Albright (Freshman, Cortland, pitcher/first baseman/outfielder, .338 batting average, .449 on-base percentage, .415 slugging percentage, three doubles, one triple, eight RBIs, 21 runs scored, seven stolen bases, 29.2 innings pitched, 1.43 ERA, 0.98 WHIP, 38 strikeouts)
Cal, just a couple years behind his brother Caden, showed baseball talent runs all throughout the Albright family this season. After showing signs as an eighth grader, Albright broke out in his freshman year. He slapped the ball all over and showed his contact ability but showed true potential on the mound. He put together as impressive a season as one could see pitching and if he keeps taking strides, he’ll be one of the top names to watch in the coming years.
Mitchell Earle (Senior, Homer, pitcher/shortstop, 48.0 innings pitched, 1.02 ERA, 0.83 WHIP, 91 strikeouts)
Earle was a true ace and one of the best pitchers in the state this year, let alone the area. The LeMoyne commit added a slider and began developing a changeup to complement his dynamic fastball/curveball combo to give himself more options against top hitters. Earle also dramatically improved his command, walking just 10 batters all season and working the ball all over the zone.
Ethan Johnson (Senior catcher/first baseman/pitcher, .315 batting average, .585 on-base percentage, .389 slugging percentage, two doubles, one triple, 22 RBIs, 22 runs scored, 15 stolen bases, 32.1 innings pitched, 32.1 innings pitched, 2.31 ERA, 1.33 WHIP, 32 strikeouts)
Johnson hit right in the heart of Cortland’s order all season, and for good reason. The senior, who led the Purple Tigers in RBIs, produced runs any way he could. Not only was Johnson successful on the offensive end, but he was a big arm in the rotation and always performed at a high level defensively at catcher. Johnson is heading to Utica University in the fall to continue his baseball career.
Luke Landis (Senior, Moravia, catcher/pitcher/first baseman, .439 batting average, .493 on-base percentage, .614 slugging percentage, five doubles, one triple, one home run, 25 RBIs, 12 runs scored, five stolen bases, 38.2 innings pitched, 3.26 ERA, 1.35 WHIP, 59 strikeouts)
Landis hit plenty of frozen ropes throughout the season at the plate. Placed right in the heart of Moravia’s lineup, Landis did his job –– getting on base and producing runs at a consistent rate –– at the plate more times than not. The senior was also a great leader on all levels, whether at catcher, pitcher or in the dugout, and found a way to keep the Blue Devils locked in.
Caden Albright (Junior, Cortland, shortstop, .469 batting average, .585 on-base percentage, .641 slugging percentage, nine doubles, one triple, 20 RBIs, 5 runs scored, 10 stolen bases)
Albright continued his impressive high school career with another successful spring. Albright was a hitting machine for Cortland, putting together nine multi-hit games and recording a hit in all but three games. The junior showed great patience at the plate, waiting for his pitch to drive. Albright also flashed the leather at shortstop, recording 45 putouts with just three errors.
Owen Johnson (Sophomore, Cortland, second baseman/pitcher, .394 batting average, .452 on-base percentage, .500 slugging percentage, three doubles, two triples, 14 RBIs, 12 runs scored, eight stolen bases, 12.2 innings pitched, 0.00 ERA, 1.18 WHIP, 14 strikeouts)
Johnson broke out as a sophomore, especially at the plate. Johnson hit the ball everywhere in 2024, finishing second on the team in batting average. Johnson looked good on the mound as a freshman and it led to an even more successful season on the mound in his second year.
Tristan Allen (Senior, Homer, first baseman/pitcher, .373 batting average, .418 on-base percentage, .490 slugging percentage, three doubles, one home run, eight RBIs, 11 runs scored, six stolen bases)
Allen was the most feared hitter in Homer’s order and was pitched accordingly. Allen continued hitting the ball hard after a monster junior season, but ran into a little less batted ball luck. He was also a savant at first base, bailing out his teammates on low throws and making some crafty tags on pick-off plays.
Blair Mulcahy (Sophomore, McGraw, shortstop/pitcher, .500 batting average, .551 on-base percentage, .806 slugging percentage, three doubles, eight triples, 24 RBIs, 30 runs scored, 15 stolen bases, 43.1 innings pitched, 5.18 ERA, 1.55 WHIP, 67 strikeouts)
Mulcahy broke out as a sophomore on both sides of the ball, but really became a problem in the three-hole for McGraw. He was always ready to jump on an early fastball and punish it and complemented that by playing a smooth shortstop. Mulcahy also dominated hitters on the mound with a riding fastball, but occasionally put runners on and got himself in trouble.
Calob Sutton (Sophomore, McGraw, outfielder/shortstop/pitcher, .404 batting average, .493 on-base percentage, .596 slugging percentage, three doubles, one triple, two home runs, nine RBIs, 26 runs scored, 11 stolen bases)
Sutton was a quiet contributor atop McGraw’s lineup. He loved to jump on pitches early in the count but had the wherewithal to work the count if he couldn’t swing on the first or second pitch. Sutton also had sneaky pop and could beat outfielders if they weren’t on their toes.
Zeke Mohat (Senior, Tully, outfielder/pitcher, .483 batting average, .615 on-base percentage, .586 slugging percentage, three triples, nine RBIs, 26 runs scored, 31 stolen bases, 40.1 innings pitched, 0.69 ERA, 0.82 WHIP, 49 strikeouts)
Mohat was the best player on both sides of the ball for Tully, leading off and throwing the most innings. The senior was always a tough at bat at the dish and was more than willing to work a walk to keep an inning going. Mohat had the ability to throw a complete game, but was best when he could empty the tank in three or four inning spurts and blow away hitters from the left side.
Eli Landis (Sophomore, Moravia, outfielder/pitcher, .548 batting average, .594 on-base percentage, .613 slugging percentage, four doubles, 11 RBIs, 30 runs scored, 11 stolen bases, 14.1 innings pitched, 3.91 ERA, 1.67 WHIP, 22 strikeouts)
Landis was everything one wants in a lead-off hitter. It’s tough to find a game where Landis wasn’t productive at the dish. He consistently reached base, often with a hit, stole bases and scored runs. Just a sophomore, Landis showed great strides after a successful freshman season and the sky’s the limit for him with two years left.
SOFTBALL
Remi Stull (Eighth grader, McGraw, pitcher/shortstop, 67.1 innings pitched, 5.21 ERA, 1.26 WHIP, 53 strikeouts, .373 batting average, .568 on-base percentage, .549 slugging percentage, seven doubles, one triple, four RBIs, 30 runs scored, 22 stolen bases)
Stull looks to be a force for years to come after a big eighth-grade season. She kept an upstart McGraw team in games all year and let the lineup do what it does. Stull topped that lineup and was a terrific table-setter for the rest of the Eagles.
Kaylee Brenchley (Senior, Cincinnatus, pitcher/infielder, 45 innings pitched, 3.20 ERA, 1.36 WHIP, 40 strikeouts, .403 batting average, .420 on-base percentage, .716 slugging percentage, 10 doubles, four triples, one home run, 29 RBIs, 12 runs scored, eight stolen bases)
Brenchley was a dependable pitcher for Cincinnatus and was part of a tandem with Payton Gerrard. Brenchley was able to keep hitters off balance and let her solid defense do the work. She also hit fourth in a loaded lineup and had plenty of RBI opportunities, delivering with lots of extra base hits.
Cassie Forrest (Junior, Marathon, catcher .430 batting average, .611 on-base percentage, 31 hits, 10 doubles, two triples, 25 RBIs)
Forrest was Marathon’s best offensive player all season. She always seemed to be on base and hit runners in with the big knock consistently. Not only was she an offensive weapon, but she played stellar at the catcher position, flashing her good arm and ability to keep runners from being aggressive.
Madison Stover (Sophomore, Cincinnatus, catcher, .365 batting average, .468 on-base percentage, .481 slugging percentage, four doubles, one triple, 14 RBIs, 23 runs scored, 15 stolen bases)
Stover was an exceptional defensive catcher and helped Cincinnatus avoid giving up extra bases. She rarely let passed balls by, had a good arm to throw out base stealers and took advantage of free outs when presented to her. Stover was also a solid bat at the top of the Lions’ order and was often on base for her teammates.
Sophie Mayer (Junior, Cortland, shortstop, .449 batting average, .557 on-base percentage, .735 slugging percentage, two doubles, three triples, two home runs, 20 RBIs, 18 runs scored, eight stolen bases)
Mayer was good in her sophomore season, but she stepped it up as a junior. Mayer hit the ball over the field and her offensive power is backed up by her numbers. The junior shined on May 11 against Phoenix, finishing 5-for-5 with two singles, two home runs, a triple and six RBIs. Mayer flashed the leather any chance she got at shortstop too, as she has turned into a great defender.
Payton Gerrard (Sophomore, Cincinnatus, shortstop/pitcher, .525 batting average, .608 on-base percentage, .656 slugging percentage, six doubles, one triple, 14 RBIs, 29 runs scored, 24 stolen bases, 47 innings pitched, 3.45 ERA, 1.19 WHIP, 62 strikeouts)
Gerrard was an all-around star and cemented herself as one this year. She was a slick fielder in the middle infield and a true leader defensively. Gerrard also slapped her way on base plenty and was able to turn on a ball if a pitcher came inside. The sophomore also dominated in the circle with electric stuff, getting plenty of swing and miss to counter Brenchley.
Lucy Finch (Sophomore, Cincinnatus, shortstop/second baseman, .470 batting average, .500 on-base percentage, .758 slugging percentage, three doubles, five triples, two home runs, 14 RBIs, 29 runs scored, 23 stolen bases)
Finch was at the plate to swing the bat and did lots of damage when she did so. The sophomore was an extra base machine and commanded respect from opposing pitchers and outfielders. Finch also made strides in the infield, playing shortstop at a high level when Gerrard pitched and patrolling second base with Brenchley in the circle.
Laci Prignon (Senior, Dryden, shortstop, .541 batting average, .569 on-base percentage, .729 slugging percentage, one home run, 26 hits, three doubles, one triple)
Prignon was a huge reason for Dryden’s success on the offensive end. Hitting third in the order, she used a red-hot start to the season and seemed to always be good for two to three hits a game. Prignon had underrated power and when she got bat on ball, it flew all over the yard.
Marissa Allen (Senior, Marathon, .343 batting average, .437 on-base percentage, 22 hits, one double, one triple, one home run, 16 stolen bases)
Allen did it all at the top of the order for Marathon. She was a true lead-off hitter that got on base, stole bases and scored a lot of runs. What is most impressive about Allen is her speed and defense in the outfield. Her all-around play and vocal leadership will be missed by the Olympians moving forward.
Julia Wortley (Sophomore, Tully, utility player, .558 batting average, .596 on-base percentage, .814 slugging percentage, eight doubles, one home run, six RBIs, 15 runs scored)
Wortley had a breakout sophomore season playing all over the field for Tully. She spent most of her time in the middle infield and corner outfield, but did log 20.1 innings in the circle. Wortley was a real threat at the plate though, spraying the ball to all fields and showing an ability to handle almost any pitch she saw.
Lashley Heredia-Castillo (Sophomore, Moravia, .385 batting average, .467 on-base percentage, .468 slugging percentage, 20 hits, three home runs, two doubles, three triples, 23 stolen bases)
Speed kills, especially with Heredia-Castillo. The sophomore shined this season, using a strong swing at the plate and aggressiveness and speed on the bases. Heredia-Castillo fit right into the game plan that Moravia had –– getting on base and being aggressive once there. She’ll without a doubt be a big piece of the program moving forward.
––––––
All stats and recaps were compiled by Sports Editor Paul Cifonelli and Sports Reporter Matt Czeitner.
